As the world continues to celebrate the release of the second installment of blockbuster the two-part Wicked film series, Wicked: For Good, Tony winner Darren Criss has joined in on the fun, recording and sharing a cover of "I'm Not That Girl" with band Third Reprise. 

The Maybe Happy Ending star lent vocals to the electrifying spin on Elphaba's act-one ballad, which was accentuated with plenty of guitar, drums, and epic background vocals. See the performance in the video below.

Criss recently returned to Broadway, joining Maybe Happy Ending once again on November 5 in the role he originated as Oliver. Criss, the 2025 Tony winner for Best Leading Actor in a Musical (and for Best Musical as one of the show's co-producers), had been away from the show on a leave of absence since August 31.

Starring Criss alongside Helen J. Shen, Maybe Happy Ending opened at the Belasco November 12, 2024. The musical, featuring a Tony-winning book and score by Hue Park and Will Aronson, is the most Tony-winning show of last season. With Criss back at the Belasco, the musicial's original Broadway cast is back in full.