A TRUSTED THEATRE RESOURCE SINCE 1884
Broadway Shows
News
Jobs
Build-Your-Own Playbill
Win Free Tickets
Playbill Store
Site Navigation
Broadway Shows
News
Jobs
Build-Your-Own Playbill
Win Free Tickets
Playbill Store
What’s Playing on Broadway and Beyond
Broadway Shows
Off-Broadway Shows
Broadway Weekly Schedule
Broadway Rush, Lotto, SRO Policies
Upcoming Broadway Shows
Playbill Ticket Discounts
Playbill Editorial
News — Broadway, Off-Broadway, and Beyond
Special Features
Photo Galleries
Videos - My Life in the Theatre, Getting Ready, More
Seth Rudetsky’s Column
Classic Arts
Industry Resources
Jobs
Broadway Grosses
Playbill Vault - Shows, Actors, and More
Current and Future Broadway Theatre Bookings
Upcoming Cast Recordings
More from Playbill
Build-Your-Own Playbill
Playbill Emails
Playbill Store
Playbill Travel & Cruises
Playbill Podcast
Games
Advertise with Us
Broadway Shows
News
Jobs
Build-Your-Own Playbill
Win Free Tickets
Playbill Store
0 Related Articles
Reviews: What Do The Critics Think of
Every Brilliant Thing
Starring Daniel Radcliffe?
Writer Patrick Lazour Will Star in Select Performances of His
Night Side Songs
Bedlam to Stage 4-Person Version of Shakespeare’s
Othello
If You Want to Get Called on at
Every Brilliant Thing
, Don't Be Too Eager, Says Daniel
Photos: Get a 1st Look at John Lithgow-Led
Giant
on Broadway
0 New
Search
Erstwhile Susan
Broadway
Original
Erstwhile Susan
Broadway
Original
Gaiety Theatre
1547 Broadway at W. 46th St., New York, NY, New York, NY
SYNOPSIS:
playwright:
Marian De Forest
People (19)
Samuel Aidenfelder
Joseph Yoder
(Original)
Hugh Chilvers
Robert Marsh
(Original)
Anita Clarendon
Mrs. Winthrop
(Original)
John W. Cope
Barnaby Dreary
(Original)
Harry Cowley
Absalom Puntz
(Original)
Madeline Delmar
Barnabetta Dreary
(Original)
Anne Faystone
Alice Meredith
(Original)
Mrs. Fiske
Juliet Miller
(Original)
Robert Stowe Gill
Jacob Dreary
(Original)
Maude Longnecker
Em. Wackernagel
(Original)
Owen Meech
Emanuel Dreary
(Original)
Wylda Millison
Ramah Schwenkfelders
(Original)
John Daly Murphy
Abel Buchter
(Original)
Edward H. Robins
Performer
(Original)
Marie Sasee
Jennie Getz
(Original)
Henry B. Vogel
Abraham Wackernagel
(Original)
View All Current Cast
Samuel Aidenfelder
Joseph Yoder
(Original)
Hugh Chilvers
Robert Marsh
(Original)
Anita Clarendon
Mrs. Winthrop
(Original)
John W. Cope
Barnaby Dreary
(Original)
Harry Cowley
Absalom Puntz
(Original)
Madeline Delmar
Barnabetta Dreary
(Original)
Anne Faystone
Alice Meredith
(Original)
Mrs. Fiske
Juliet Miller
(Original)
Robert Stowe Gill
Jacob Dreary
(Original)
Maude Longnecker
Em. Wackernagel
(Original)
Owen Meech
Emanuel Dreary
(Original)
Wylda Millison
Ramah Schwenkfelders
(Original)
John Daly Murphy
Abel Buchter
(Original)
Edward H. Robins
Performer
(Original)
Marie Sasee
Jennie Getz
(Original)
Henry B. Vogel
Abraham Wackernagel
(Original)
View All Cast
Marian De Forest
Writer
Helen R. Martin
Based on the novel "Barnabetta"
Corey-Williams-Riter, Inc.
Producer
View All Production Team
Pro Info
Opening Date
Jan
18
1916
Closing Date
Jun
1
1916
Performances
167
as of Mar 13, 2026
Find Theatre Souvenirs Here
The Playbill Store
Click to Shop Now