A TRUSTED THEATRE RESOURCE SINCE 1884
Broadway Shows
News
Jobs
Build-Your-Own Playbill
Win Free Tickets
Playbill Store
Site Navigation
A Trusted Theatre Resource Since 1884
Broadway Shows
News
Jobs
Build-Your-Own Playbill
Win Free Tickets
Playbill Store
What’s Playing on Broadway and Beyond
Broadway Shows
Off-Broadway Shows
Broadway Weekly Schedule
Broadway Rush, Lotto, SRO Policies
Upcoming Broadway Shows
Playbill Ticket Discounts
Playbill Editorial
News — Broadway, Off-Broadway, and Beyond
Special Features
Photo Galleries
Videos - My Life in the Theatre, Getting Ready, More
Seth Rudetsky’s Column
Classic Arts
Industry Resources
Jobs
Broadway Grosses
Playbill Vault - Shows, Actors, and More
Current and Future Broadway Theatre Bookings
Upcoming Cast Recordings
More from Playbill
Build-Your-Own Playbill
Playbill Emails
Playbill Store
Playbill Travel & Cruises
Playbill Podcast
Games
Advertise with Us
Broadway Shows
News
Jobs
Build-Your-Own Playbill
Win Free Tickets
Playbill Store
0 Related Articles
Krystal Joy Brown, T.R. Knight, Michael Urie, More Join
Boys From Syracuse
Concert
This Month, the Original Broadway Production of
The Color Purple
Turns 20; The Revival Turns
Watch: Ne-Yo Takes a Broadway Debut Curtain Call in
Hell's Kitchen
Jason Robert Brown Says
Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil
Is Still Waiting for
Little Bear Ridge Road
's Micah Stock Ponders, 'Is There Life After Laurie Metcalf?'
0 New
Search
Who Was That Lady I Saw You With?
Broadway
Original
close gallery
Who Was That Lady I Saw You With? Playbill - March 1958
Who Was That Lady I Saw You With?
Broadway
Original
Martin Beck Theatre
302 W. 45th St., New York, NY
SYNOPSIS:
playwright:
Norman Krasna
People (30)
Roxanne Arlen
Gloria Coogle
(Original)
Robert Burr
Evans
(Original)
Pamela Curran
Second Tenant
(Original)
Virginia de Luce
Florence Coogle
(Original)
Dan Frazer
McCarthy
(Original)
Peter Gumeny
First Tenant
(Original)
Joe Bendix
(Original)
Peter Lind Hayes
David Williams
(Original)
Mary Healy
Ann Williams
(Original)
Frank Milan
Parker
(Original)
Joan Morgan
Secretary
(Original)
Third Tenant
(Original)
Gregory Morton
Belka
(Original)
W. Edgar Rooney
Building Employee
(Original)
Wallace Rooney
Schultz
(Original)
Larry Storch
Orlov
(Original)
William Swetland
Robert Doyle
(Original)
Ray Walston
Michael Haney
(Original)
Roland Winters
Harry Powell
(Original)
Larry Blyden
Michael Haney
(Replacement)
View All Current Cast
Roxanne Arlen
Gloria Coogle
(Original)
Robert Burr
Evans
(Original)
Pamela Curran
Second Tenant
(Original)
Virginia de Luce
Florence Coogle
(Original)
Dan Frazer
McCarthy
(Original)
Peter Gumeny
First Tenant
(Original)
Joe Bendix
(Original)
Peter Lind Hayes
David Williams
(Original)
Mary Healy
Ann Williams
(Original)
Frank Milan
Parker
(Original)
Joan Morgan
Secretary
(Original)
Third Tenant
(Original)
Gregory Morton
Belka
(Original)
W. Edgar Rooney
Building Employee
(Original)
Wallace Rooney
Schultz
(Original)
Larry Storch
Orlov
(Original)
William Swetland
Robert Doyle
(Original)
Ray Walston
Michael Haney
(Original)
Roland Winters
Harry Powell
(Original)
View All Cast
Norman Krasna
Writer
Alex Segal
Director
Rouben Ter-Arutunian
Scenic Design
Ruth Morley
Costume Design
Bernard Green
Incidental Music
David Gray, Jr.
Production Stage Manager
Elbert Gruver
Stage Manager
Robert Burr
Stage Manager
Peter Gumeny
Stage Manager
Thomas Fitzgerald
Soundman
Herman Bernstein
General Manager
Maurice Winters
Company Manager
Abner D. Klipstein
Press Representative
Leland Hayward
Producer
View All Production Team
Pro Info
Opening Date
Mar
3
1958
Closing Date
Aug
30
1958
Performances
208
as of Dec 05, 2025
Inside The Playbill
close gallery
Zoom In
Zoom Out
Reset
Who Was That Lady I Saw You With? - March 1, 1958
Who Was That Lady I Saw You With? - March 1, 1958
Who Was That Lady I Saw You With? - March 1, 1958
Who Was That Lady I Saw You With? - March 1, 1958
Who Was That Lady I Saw You With? - March 1, 1958
Who Was That Lady I Saw You With? - March 1, 1958
Find Theatre Souvenirs Here
The Playbill Store
Click to Shop Now
Awards
Outer Critics Circle
1958
Outstanding Set Design
Rouben Ter-Arutunian
Winner
Tony Award
1959
Stage Technician
Thomas Fitzgerald
Nominee
Shows That Opened That Season: 1958–1959
The Waltz of the Toreadors
International Soiree
Two Gentlemen of Verona
Back to Methuselah
Martha Graham and Company
View All