• 
• Leo Penn
• Bert
  

• 
• David Clarke
• Raymond
  

• 
• Eileen Heckart
• Agnes
  

Replacement

• 
• Gloria Marlowe
• Patricia
  

• 
• J. Carrol Naish
• Gus
  

Replacement

• 
• Russell Collins
• Jim
  

• 
• William Biff McGuire
• Kenneth
  

• 
• Van Heflin
• Larry
  

• 
• Jack Warden
• Frank
  

• 
• Richard Davalos
• Jerry
  

• 
• Antony Vorno
• William
  

• 
• Curt Conway
• Tom
  

Replacement

• 
• Tom Pedi
• Mechanic
  

• 
• Ralph Bell
• Mister Eagle
  

• 
• Arthur Miller
• Writer
  

• 
• Johnny Black
• Featured Song ("Paper Doll")
  

• 
• Martin Ritt
• Director
  

• 
• Boris Aronson
• Scenic Design
  

• 
• Helene Pons
• Costume Design
  

• 
• Leland Watson
• Lighting Design
  

• 
• Harry Young
• Stage Manager
  

• 
• Milton Carney
• Stage Manager
  

• 
• Robert Carrington
• Stage Manager
  

• 
• Max Allentuck
• General Manager
  

• 
• James D. Proctor
• Press Representative
  

• 
• Merle Debuskey
• Press Representative
  

• 
• Louis A. Lotito
• Coronet Theatre Managing Director
  

• 
• Kermit Bloomgarden
• Producer
  

• 
• Robert Whitehead
• Producer
  

• 
• Roger L. Stevens
• Producer