Stage and screen star Cheyenne Jackson, who will return for the sixth season of American Horror Story, released his latest solo album, Renaissance, in June on the PS Classics label. Adapted from his one-man show Music of the Mad Men Era, the recording—which features a 22-piece orchestra—hit the Top 10 on the Billboard “Jazz Albums” chart in its first week of release. Below, the acclaimed singing actor reveals the Broadway performances and shows that most affected him as part of the audience.

The Full Monty

First Broadway show I ever saw. Caught a matinee my first full day in the city. “Breeze Off the River” gutted me.  

Hand to God

Saw it in its first incarnation Off Off-Broadway. Affected me deeply.  At intermission I called a Broadway producer friend to tell them to get down there immediately...They'd already seen it...twice, and it was already in the planning stages for future Broadway glory.

The Light in the Piazza

So beautiful it hurt.

Hamilton

Reminded me what is possible with the power of musical theatre.

The Seagull

Carey Mulligan and Kristin Scott Thomas made me understand Chekhov like I never had before.

Jersey Boys

Crazy good. The original boys were magnificent, and the staging and choreography were thrilling.

Monty Python's Spamalot

Fully committed comedy. Sara Ramirez and Chris Sieber killed me.  

The Normal Heart

One of the most electrifying nights I've ever spent in the theatre.  I'll never forget Joe Mantello's performance as long as I live. 

The Book of Mormon

I played Elder Price in a couple early workshops, so I knew what I was in for, but what Andrew [Rannells], Josh [Gad], Nikki [M. James] and the rest of the cast pulled off was heartbreakingly perfect.

Billy Elliot

Electricity.