Samuel D. Hunter

Drama Desk Award
2023	Outstanding Play	A Case for the Existence of God	Nominee
2020	Outstanding Play	Greater Clements	Nominee
2019	Outstanding Play		Nominee

Lucille Lortel Award
2023	Outstanding Play	A Case for the Existence of God	Nominee

New York Drama Critics' Circle
2022	Best Play	A Case for the Existence of God	Winner

Outer Critics Circle
2019	Outstanding New Off-Broadway Play		Nominee