On October 30, ABC’s long-running reality dance competition, Dancing with the Stars, paid homage to another long-running show: Broadway’s The Phantom of the Opera. In honor of Halloween, the cast of Season 25 was split into two teams: Team Phantom of the Opera and Team Monster Mash.

Competitors Drew Scott, Emma Slater, Frankie Muniz, Witney Carson, Vanessa Lachey, Maksim Chmerkovskiy, Victoria Arlen, and Valentin Chmerkovskiy danced to “Phantom of the Opera,” from the original London cast recording. Hamilton’s Jordan Fisher remains in the race and danced as part of Team Monster Mash.

His individual number was a Paso to “Animals” with his partner Lindsay Arnold. Click here to watch.

Fisher made his Broadway debut as John Laurens/Philip Hamilton in Hamilton after wowing audiences nationwide as Doody in Fox’s Grease: Live.