Chris Sullivan as Noodler, Ryan Andes Admirable Chrichton, Michael Park as Cecco, Christopher Walken as Captain Hook, Austin Lesch as Bill Jukes, Christian Borle as Smee, Gary Milner as The Vicar, John Arthur Greene as Robert Mullins, Andrew Pirozzi as Pirate, Matt Wall as Skylights, Marty Lawson as Pirate
Virginia Sherwood/NBC