In a Before and After game, phrases are mashed together where the last word of the first phrase is the same as the first word of the second phrase. We've used Broadway titles, linking two Broadway titles together to create one new Before and After title. She Loves Me plus Me and My Girl becomes "She Loves Me and My Girl." The word "me" links the two titles. The clue to the new title is a mashup of the two original plots. So, for "She Love Me and My Girl" the clue might read "A perfume store clerk is involved in a romantic pen-pal relationship with the 14th heir to the Earl of Hareford."
Click through the gallery below to see you many you can name. (Note: Some title articles (the, a, an) have been excluded.)