While everything onstage takes a left turn during Broadway’s The Play That Goes Wrong, it all turns right as star Charlie Russell transforms into her opening-night look. Transferring from a hit run in London, The Play That Goes Wrong officially opened April 2 at the Lyceum Theatre—and marked the Broadway debut of producer J.J. Abrams. Celebrating her Broadway debut with the play, Russell gussied up with the help of the production’s hair supervisor, Chad Harlow, before joining the festivities at Guastavino’s in midtown Manhattan.
Flip through the photos below to watch Russell go from the queen of onstage mishaps to the belle of the ball: