• 
• Harry Guardino
• J. Bowden Hapgood
  

• 
• Angela Lansbury
• Cora Hoover Hooper
  

• 
• Lee Remick
• Fay Apple
  

• 
• Susan Borree
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  

• 
• Sterling Clark
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  One of the boys
  

• 
• Georgia Creighton
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  Osgood
  

• 
• Gabriel Dell
• Comptroller Schub
  

• 
• Don Doherty
• Dr. Detmold
  

• 
• Eugene Edwards
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  

• 
• Richard Ensslen
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  

• 
• Harvey Evans
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  John
  One of the boys
  

• 
• James Frawley
• Chief Magruder
  

• 
• Janet Hayes
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  June
  

• 
• Loren Hightower
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  

• 
• Bettye Jenkins
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  

• 
• Alan Johnson
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  Telegraph Boy
  

• 
• Patricia Kelly
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  

• 
• Jeff Killion
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  Sandwich Man
  

• 
• Barbara Lang
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  

• 
• Paula Lloyd
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  

• 
• Barbara Monte-Britton
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  

• 
• Jack Murray
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  

• 
• Peg Murray
• Mrs. Schroeder
  

• 
• Odette Phillips
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  

• 
• William Reilly
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  

• 
• Hanne Marie Reiner
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  

• 
• Larry Roquemore
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  George
  One of the boys
  

• 
• Tucker Smith
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  One of the boys
  

• 
• Arnold Soboloff
• Treasurer Cooley
  

• 
• Don Stewart
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  

• 
• Jeanne Tanzy
• Baby Joan
  

• 
• Eleonore Treiber
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  Old Lady
  

• 
• Lester Wilson
• Cookie, nurse, deputy, townsperson, pilgrim, tourist
  Martin
  

• 
• Barbara Lang
• Fay Apple
  

• 
• Peg Murray
• Cora Hoover Hooper
  

• 
• Tucker Smith
• Treasurer Cooley
  

• 
• Don Stewart
• J. Bowden Hapgood
  

• 
• Herbert Greene
• Musical Director
  

• 
• Arthur Laurents
• Book
  Director
  

• 
• Stephen Sondheim
• Music
  Lyrics
  

• 
• Herbert Ross
• Choreographer
  

• 
• William and Jean Eckart
• Scenic Design
  

• 
• Theoni V. Aldredge
• Costume Design
  

• 
• Jules Fisher
• Lighting Design
  

• 
• Don Walker
• Music Orchestrations
  

• 
• Betty Walberg
• Dance Arrangements
  

• 
• Herbert Greene
• Vocal Arrangements
  

• 
• James S. Gelb
• Production Stage Manager
  

• 
• Don Doherty
• Stage Manager
  

• 
• James D. Proctor
• Press Representative
  

• 
• Kermit Bloomgarden
• Producer
  

• 
• Diana Krasny
• Producer