Directed by Paul Takacs, performances of the the New York premiere continue through Jan. 26.
Joining Tierney is Louis Butelli (Cyclops: A Rock Opera, Sleep No More); the actors replaced the previously announced James Patrick Nelson and Jonathan Tindle.
The production features a translation of Jon Fosse's script by Olivier Award-winning British playwright Simon Stephens (Harper Regan, Bluebird).
"A glorious afternoon on the water turns into a devastating meditation on life and the depths of friendship," press notes state. "Two friends spend a day boating, stopping off for drinks and a meal before pushing on to the open ocean. As the winds rise and the sea swells, the men confront each other, themselves, and the inexorable mystery of fate."
Tickets and more information are available by calling (212) 279-4200 or visiting 59e59.org.