The CD of the 1960 "Bell Telephone Hour" version of Groucho Marx in The Mikado [VAI] has sat upon my shelf for several months, for several reasons: Groucho as Ko-Ko, the Lord High Executioner, sounds like a stunt; this was Groucho turning 70, and I generally find his post-1950 acting performances more grating than funny (while enjoying his interviews and game shows); to fit within the Bell Telephone Company's hour, the operetta had to be shoehorned into 52 minutes; the cast album of this production — recorded by Columbia, currently available on CD from DRG — did not leave me aching to see it; and finally, just how interesting can a cut-down 1960 TV version of The Mikado starring Groucho Marx be? Out of a sense of obligation, I finally watched the thing. And I was wrong.
Yes, it is cut down; but I usually find The Mikado overlong, anyway. And this is not just arbitrarily cut by some TV hack; Martyn Green, the renowned Savoyard, adapted and produced it. So it plays pretty well considering the time restraints. The supporting cast offers some welcome performances. Robert Rounseville — who several years earlier created the title role in Candide — makes a charming Nanki-Poo. Stanley Holloway is very much in evidence as Pooh-Bah, and the Katisha of the occasion is an extremely funny Helen Traubel.
For the Mikado they have enlisted Broadway veteran Dennis King, who starred in the 1920s operetta hits Rose-Marie and The Three Musketeers. King and Green appeared together in the ill-fated 1956 musical Shangri-La. Green looks quite fit in his on-camera introduction, belying the fact that six months earlier he was in an elevator accident in a parking garage which resulted in the emergency amputation of his leg on the grimy floor, apparently without anesthesia.
The staging is stylish, clever and pretty funny. True, this is a "Bell Telephone Hour" production, but it looks pretty good. (It was telecast in color, but all that seems to survive is the black & white kinescope from which this release derives.) Special features include the commercials from the original telecast — which are thankfully not permitted to interrupt the operetta — and a new audio commentary from Groucho-expert Dick Cavett, Barbara Meister (who plays Pitti-Sing), and Melinda Marx Leung, who at the age of 13 played Peep-Bo, one of those little maids from school. She comments that it was her father's lifelong dream to play Ko-Ko.
The big question is "how is Groucho?," seemingly the reason for this venture. In a word, he is a delight. He is thoroughly at home in the genre; The Cocoanuts and Animal Crackers, his early stage musicals, were clearly influenced by G&S, with Groucho as the patter-singing comedian. Here, he doesn't miss a beat or a leer or a gag. He spits out his words with great skill, flits about the scenery like a firefly, takes great advantage of a malfunctioning prop fan (or is it planned)? His courtship scenes with Traubel are perfect, summoning up all those years with Margaret Dumont; and all is won he throws a bit of his Capt. Spalding hornpipe into "There is beauty of the bellow in the blast."
All The Way
Bullets Over Broadway
Of Mice and Men
The Cripple of Inishmaan
The Realistic Joneses
The Velocity of Autumn
Tony n' Tina's Wedding